Question:

A 2 GAL, salg glaze crock NO MAJOR damage. I am looking for a value estimate on them… round about estimate

thank you very much

Answer:

With the weak decoration and spider crack in the front the value would be in the area of $75. Al

Question:

Hello,

  I have a 5 gallon Red Wing locking lid jar. It is complete and in absolute perfect mint condition. The main jar body, from the bottom up, is about 3/4 white/cream and 1/4 dark brown up to the rounded shoulder and all dark brown from the shoulder to the top of the lid. The original handle and locking mechanism are complete, with very light surface rust. Markings on the jar are a cobalt 5 and the red wing oval below that. There is NO wing on the jar. The markings are dark and crisp with no smearing or light spots. What is the approximate date of this jar and a price range for it? I do not have a photo. This jar does not have a regular shoulder like a shoulder jug, this shoulder is smooth and rounded.Thanks in advance for any info you can give me.

                                                              Dan

Answer:

Dan, your Red Wing packing jar with the Albany top and just the number 5 & Red Wing oval does not carry as high of a value as those packing jars which are all white and carry the gallon-age, red wing & oval.  Your packing jar in perfect condition has a value between $150 & $175.  Al Kohlman

Question:

 The first pic is a rectangular cone top like the one I sent before but it is smaller 3 1/4 inches high.

The next one is a little different and I am wondering if that is Red Wing?

The third picture is 2 more like the ones I sent before but I did not realize I had 2 different sizes.  One is  4 inches high by 1 1/4 inch in diameter and the others are 4 1/2 by 1 5/8.  Is the value the same for both?

I would like to get a value on these please.

Thanks,

George

Answer:

George, your first photo with the two Mercury  jugs with the * in the oval are Red Wing.  The value on these is between $200 & $225.  The Mercury jug in the middle, I have never seen before and could be a reproduction, from another pottery or a Red Wing Mercury jug that has never been seen before (but don’t think so).  So no value or history on this one.  The last Red Wing Mercury jug as a value between $150 & $200.   Al Kohlman

Question:

Dear Expert,

I recently picked up a 4 gallon Water Cooler, with spigot but no lid.

It is in very good condition no chips or cracks.

I was wondering what the value is?

It doesn’t have any handles on the sides, does this make it any older/rarer?

Thank-you!

Mike

Answer:

Mike, you have a hand turned Red Wing water cooler.  This is the earliest zinc glazed water cooler produced by Red Wing and the most desired.  If in perfect condition, the value on your cooler is between $400 to $500 as it sits.   It will require a Red Wing button water cooler lid.  Al Kohlman

Question:

This crock is almost perfect. One small chip on one handle. Side stamped with bright blue butterfly. What is the value?

Are there different stamps that were used or just one. Do they affect value? Also it has a couple spots of blue under the glaze away from the butterfly. Does that hurt the value?
Thank you Brad

Answer:

Brad, these Red Wing butter flies used to be higher, but have come down in value as has everything else in this economy. Value on your 15 gallon side stamped Red Wing butter fly is around $2000. 

I have only seen the Red Wing Stoneware stamp on the butterfly, but there could be a Minnesota Stoneware Company stamp as well as these potters moved around. The only thing that will affect the price of butterfly you have is either stamped or not stamped. The couple of blue marks under the butterfly will not hurt it’s value.  al

  Al Kohlman

Question:

Hello Al
I picked up a 10 Gallon Crock and would like to know when it was made and what the markings are and value.  I am including pictures of it.  No cracks although it does have a small chip on the handle, which I also am sending a picture of that. I do know that it is a salt glaze and has a dark brown glaze on the inside.  Any help identifying this would be greatly appreciated.
Mike

Answer:

Mike, your 10 gallon salt glazed crock was produced between 1867 & 1895.  The decoration is called lazy 8 target which is the most common decoration. Also, a number of other potteries used this decoration.  From what I can see on your 10 gallon Lazy 8 target crock, it looks to be Red Wing.  Not being signed and in perfect condition, the value would be between $250 & $300.   Al Kohlman

Question:

Hello, and sorry if I’m doing this the wrong way. 

My parents have a red wing crock, they gave me the task of finding out around how much it’s worth. 

I’m young, so I’m not sure what to do on your site, I suppose you need a membership for appraisals. 

However I was wondering if you knew someone who would know an estimated price for an: 8 Gallon Red Wing Stoneware Crock, with wire handles patented around 1918 or so, it also has a sort of fountain, or self drain tap looking thing sticking out of the bottom. It has a “Button” lid but it’s broken in half… 

Thank you for your time in reading this, and I’m sorry if you can’t help ^ ^  

 Hope to hear back from you either way. Take care. Nathan

Answer:

Nathan, first of all, the lid on top of your 8 gallon Red Wing crock is not a Red Wing piece.  Also, the crack is quite severe, with this being said, there would be no value on that lid.  Your 8 gallon Red Wing crock was produced between 1915 & 1930.  Also, you should remove the spigot and see if that hole was drilled by someone or if it is original.  If it is original, the inside of the hole will be glazed over.  If not, you will see the unglazed clay and there may also be chips around the hole on the inside of the crock.   If the hole was drilled and not original, then the value will drop to at least half of what I estimate for you.  Value as I see your crock $100 to $125.  Al Kohlman

Question:

Dear Expert,

I recently picked up a 4 gallon Water Cooler, with spigot but no lid.

It is in very good condition no chips or cracks.

I was wondering what the value is?

It doesn’t have any handles on the sides, does this make it any older/rarer?

Thank-you!

Mike

Answer:

Mike, with no handles on your Red Wing Water Cooler, it could very well be an older cooler.  Would need to see a photo of it to tell for sure. Without seeing a photo, my best and safest guess is $300 (with no lid or spigot).  That is for a perfect piece with no damage.  Al Kohlman

Question:

Hello!

I received this 2 gallon crock as a gift, and recently found the 4 and 3 gallon jugs and purchased them at an antique resale shop.

Since my family is from the Redwing area, and I’m all the way down in San Antonio, TX, I took a chance and purchased them.

Can you tell me what they are worth please?

And, should I insure them?

Thanks!

Katie

Answer:

Katie, the value on your 4 gallon Red Wing shoulder jug is around $75, the 3 gallon shoulder jug $60 & 2 gallon Red Wintg crock with 2 inch wing $45 to $55.  Al Kohlman

Question:

Dear Al,
   I found a piece coming up for auction and I was curious on the value and if this is for sure RW.  It is a 1 gallon advertising crock.  There are no issues with the crock other than some light flaking on the bottom.  It has a bar handled 1 gallon pedal lid with it.  The crock says line 1  Eureka Bazaar Co.  Line 2 “WHERE CASH IS KING”  Line 3 Eureka S.D.  The wording has a solid square stamp around all of the wording.
 
Thanks, Dru

Answer:

Dru, the advertising 1 gallon crock with the lid from SD if in perfect condition would have a value between $700 & $1000.  Sounds like a nice piece.  Al Kohlman